Hulk Hogan: Best Babyface: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1982-1991), Pro Wrestling Torch (1989-1991); Most Popular Wrestler of the Year: Pro Wrestling Illustrated (1985) (1989) (1990); Feud of the Year: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1986), Pro Wrestling Illustrated (1986); Most Unimproved: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1994-1996); Most Charismatic: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1985-1987) (1989-1991); Most Overrated: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1985-1986) (1994-1998); Readers' Least Favorite Wrestler: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1985-1986) (1991) (1994-1999), Pro Wrestling Torch (1994-1998); Worst Match of the Year: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1987) (1995-1998), Pro Wrestling Torch (1995-1998); Tailspin of the Year: Pro Wrestling Torch (1991); Inspirational Wrestler of the Year: Pro Wrestling Illustrated (1983, 1999); Wrestler of the Year: Pro Wrestling Illustrated (1987) (1991) (1994); Most Hated Wrestler of the Year: Pro Wrestling Illustrated (1996, 1998); Match of the Year: Pro Wrestling Illustrated (1985) (1988) (1990); Worst Feud of the Year: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1991, 1995, 1998); Worst Wrestler: Pro Wrestling Torch (1995-1998), Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1997); Most Overpushed: Pro Wrestling Torch (1994-1997); Worst on Interviews: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1995), Pro Wrestling Torch (1995); Worst Wrestling Maneuver: Pro Wrestling Torch (1994) (1996-1998); Comeback of the Year: Pro Wrestling Illustrated (1994, 2002); Worst Personality: Pro Wrestling Torch (1994-1995); Most Embarrassing Wrestler: Pro Wrestling Torch (1996, 1998), Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1995-1996, 1999); Heel of the Year: Pro Wrestling Torch (1997); Best Box Office Draw: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1997)
Ricky Steamboat: Match of the Year: Pro Wrestling Torch (1989), Pro Wrestling Illustrated (1987) (1989), Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1987) (1989); Tag Team of the Year: Pro Wrestling Illustrated (1977), Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1983); Rookie of the Year: Pro Wrestling Illustrated (1977); Editors' Award: Pro Wrestling Illustrated (1995);
Arn Anderson: Feud of the Year: Pro Wrestling Illustrated (1987); Tag Team of the Year: Pro Wrestling Illustrated (1989) (1991), Pro Wrestling Torch (1989); Best on Interviews: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1990); Worst Match of the Year: Pro Wrestling Torch (1996), Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1996); Editors' Award: Pro Wrestling Illustrated (1997);
Andre the Giant: Match of the Year: Pro Wrestling Illustrated (1981), (1988); Most Popular Wrestler of the Year: Pro Wrestling Illustrated (1977) (1982); Most Hated Wrestler of the Year: Pro Wrestling Illustrated (1988); Editors' Award: Pro Wrestling Illustrated (1993); Worst Wrestler: Pro Wrestling Torch (1988) (1989), Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1989) (1991-1992); Worst Tag Team of the Year: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1990-1991); Worst Match of the Year: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1987) (1989); Worst Feud of the Year: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1984) (1986) (1989); Most Embarrassing Wrestler: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1989); Feud of the Year: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1981);
"Nature Boy" Ric Flair: Wrestler of the Year: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1981-1986) (1989-1990) (1992), Pro Wrestling Illustrated (1981) (1984-1986) (1989) (1992), Pro Wrestling Torch (1988-1992); Most Outstanding Wrestler: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1986-1987), Pro Wrestling Torch (1989-1992); Best Heel: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1990), Pro Wrestling Torch (1990) (1995); Feud of the Year: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1989), Pro Wrestling Illustrated (1987-1990), Pro Wrestling Torch (1989) (1992); Best on Interviews: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1991-1992) (1994), Pro Wrestling Torch (1992-1994); Most Charismatic: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1980) (1983-1984) (1993); Match of the Year: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1983) (1986) (1988-1989), Pro Wrestling Illustrated (1983-1984) (1986) (1989), Pro Wrestling Torch (1988-1989) (1993); Readers Personal Favorite Wrestler: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1984-1993) (1996), Pro Wrestling Torch (1992-1994); Worst Match of the Year: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1996), Pro Wrestling Torch (1996); Worst Feud of the Year: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1990); Most Hated Wrestler of the Year: Pro Wrestling Illustrated (1978) (1987); Rookie of the Year: Pro Wrestling Illustrated (1975); Career Tailspin of the Year: Pro Wrestling Torch (1994);
Shohei "Giant" Baba: Worst Tag Team of the Year: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1990-1991); Best Booker: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1989-1991); Promoter of the Year: Wrestling Observer Newsletter (1990-1994);